A Separate Peace is a novel told entirely in flashback, by a narrator—Gene Gene's status as an unreliable narrator creates a problem of sympathy that persists and how these concepts help define the relationship between Gene and Finny. Throughout the novel, Gene and Finny's relationship develops and changes as Gene's insecurities indirectly cost Finny his life. Initially, Gene and Finny begin. Gene shows his weakness for Finny on page nine, with the tree The push-pull between them is already a major issue in the book in btcmu.infoaver. com/a-separate-peace/study-guide/summary-chapters
For Gene, then, Finny represents another version of himself, only better and more powerful. Without even trying, Finny shows Gene up in the most basic, physical way.
Even more frustrating, Finny accepts his shorter than average height without difficulty, while the unconfident Gene tries to embellish his own physical stature by adding a half-inch. When Finny hears this, he virtually cuts Gene down to size by attesting flatly that they are the same height. Gene cannot lie about himself, it seems, because his other self — as like him as his shadow — will speak the truth.
The "shadow" side of the double expresses Gene's mixed feelings about Finny from the start. Some critics have identified Finny as Gene's "Doppelganger," another self, wild and uncontrollable, that Gene loves but feels he must destroy. Gene is the good boy, the theory explains, the student who wants to obey, but is prevented by dark forces beyond his control, represented by Finny. Throughout the novel, Gene's preference for an orderly life is disrupted by Finny's whims, impulsive and dangerous.
As much as Gene enjoys these occasional thrills, he feels threatened — both academically and personally — by Finny's freedom. At one point, Gene even becomes convinced that Finny's outings and forbidden jaunts are a deliberate attempt to sabotage Gene's plans to become the valedictorian. Since Gene's academic ambitions are so close to his heart, so crucial a part of his self-image, the suspicion horrifies and angers him. Given this tension, Gene's instinctive jouncing of the limb might represent a kind of self-defense: Gene's action, then, takes away Finny's power to disrupt Gene's orderly progress towards conventional adulthood.
The Relationship Between Gene & Finny Essay
After the fall, Gene does not have to fear the consequences of Finny's unthinking action. The irony, of course, is that Gene's own unthinking action will have terrible consequences of its own. As one a scholar and the other an athlete, Gene and Finny have been complementary selves — their abilities completing each other in friendship. After the fall, Finny determines to make the union of selves real in Gene, by training him to excel in sports as well as academics.
In this case, the soldier was Gene and the wounded ally is Finny. Before the fall, Finny decides to visit the beach and forces Gene to come with him, instead of going to school.
The Relationship Between Gene & Finny Essay Example for Free
A while later, Finny dies because of a second leg break, where bone marrow escaped from his leg bone, then into his blood stream and then stopped his heart. I could not escape a feeling that his was my own funeral, and you do not cry in that case.
- A Separate Peace
His alter ego, best friend and constant source of energy has been taken away and replaced by nothing. In conclusion, the affection that Gene and Finny have for each other is symbolic to that of a soldier and a wounded ally during combat because Finny thought greatly of Gene for going to the beach and Gene feeling that a part of him dies with the death of his best pal, Finny. This is symbolic of war because, at times, soldiers do not know who the enemy is, if there some force to be afraid and what the consequences of their actions will mean.
A Separate Peace: Relationship Between Phineas and Gene - words
After the first incident, where Finny falls from the tree there is an investigation, head by Brinker Hadley, a pompous young man who enjoys giving orders. During the interrogation, Finny, no longer able to bare the allegations placed against his friend, Gene, that claim he jounces the limb, which causes him to fall and break his leg, he then runs out of the interrogation. The impairment that Finny sustains from the fall a shattered leg results, in the lose of his agility.
Consequently, he then falls down the stairs and breaks his leg for a second time. Gene, later that night, rushes to the Informatory to see how his friend is doing.
This quotation proves that Gene is confused because he does not know where he belongs and if Finny was indeed, still his friend. Furthermore, Gene is confused due to his uncertainties of life and he assumes that Finny needed him, without actually knowing that someone he is close too, may or may not need him. I was on active duty all my time at school; I killed my enemy there… All of them [including Gene], all expect Phineas, constructed at infinite cost to themselves these Maginot Lines against this enemy they saw across the frontier, this enemy who never attacked that way-if he ever attacked at all; if he was indeed the enemy.
Furthermore, if Gene is not confused, then he would have knew who the enemy is and if this enemy really exist, then he would not have shaken the limb of tree, which is the first of many events, which leads to the death of Finny, his best pal. In addition, Gene did not know where he and his allegiance belongs and if, in fact, Finny is the enemy or even if there is an enemy.
Because the relationship between Gene and Finny is a microcosm of the outer world, Gene feels resentment for Finny; Gene and Finny have greatly affection for each other and they both undergo much confusion in life.
Thus, the inability of people to resolve their internal wars and the misunderstandings that result, not only in their suffering, but of others as well. The affection that Gene and Finny had for each other is symbolic to that of a soldier and a wounded ally during combat.